This Dolphins vs. Bills prediction centers on a lopsided quarterback matchup. Kyle McCord makes his second career start for 1-8 Miami against Josh Allen and the 8-1 Buffalo Bills. Buffalo is a 16-point favorite and the total sits at 44.5. Both numbers have moved since they opened. Below, we work through the quarterback gap and a Miami defense missing its top three defensive tackles. Then we read the market and land on the two plays that stand out.
Miami Dolphins vs. Buffalo Bills — Game Info
| Where | Highmark Stadium, Orchard Park New York |
| When | November 22 – 1:00 PM ET |
| TV | CBS |
The Quarterback Position for Miami is the Most Obvious Handicapping Angle
The quarterback gap shapes everything here. McCord took over after Malik Willis went on injured reserve with a groin and core muscle injury. In his NFL debut last week, McCord completed 17 of 32 passes in a 24-22 loss to Indianapolis. Now he faces a Buffalo team that has won five straight. Allen, meanwhile, is healthy and leads an offense averaging 31.9 points per game.
Buffalo’s defense has been just as sharp lately. The Bills have allowed 28 combined points over their last three games. They did not give up a touchdown in either of the last two. Last week’s 31-12 win over the Jets also featured James Cook’s 157 rushing yards and a career-long 74-yard touchdown run. Our Bills vs. Jets preview from last week covers how Buffalo reached 8-1.
Miami sits last in the AFC East and has dropped three straight. Still, the Dolphins compete more than the record suggests. Four of their last five losses came by one score. The bigger problem is up front. Defensive tackles Zach Sieler, Jordan Phillips and Zeek Biggers are all lost for the season. The Colts then ran for 172 yards against the thinned interior last week. According to the Sun Sentinel, safety Dante Trader Jr. and cornerback Jaylin Simpson are doubtful, while center Aaron Brewer is questionable with a concussion.
Buffalo has injury questions too. Cornerback Christian Benford and linebacker Dorian Williams are out, and tight end Dalton Kincaid is doubtful. The Bills also listed Ed Oliver as questionable with an oblique injury on Saturday, with Damar Hamlin and T.J. Sanders also questionable.
History leans heavily toward Buffalo. The Bills have won 10 straight home games against Miami and 14 of the last 16 meetings overall. However, the most recent meeting went Miami’s way, a 30-13 Dolphins win in November 2025. This is also Miami’s first trip to the new Highmark Stadium, which opened this season.
Miami Dolphins vs. Buffalo Bills Odds
| Spread | Moneyline | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dolphins | +16.0 (-112) | +850 | O 44.5 (-112) |
| Bills | -16.0 (-108) | -1500 | U 44.5 (-108) |
Odds accurate as of November 22, 2026 via TheSpread.com. Odds change, get the latest NFL Odds – Futures – Props
Miami Dolphins vs. Buffalo Bills — Who Is the Public Betting?
| Dolphins | 49% | 51% | Bills |
See the latest NFL Public Betting Splits and make smarter wagers!
The market has moved in two different ways. The spread opened at Bills -16.5 and has slipped only half a point to -16, with spread tickets split almost evenly. That small move carries little signal. The total is another story. It opened at 47 and has fallen 2.5 points to 44.5, the larger and more meaningful shift. At -1500, the Bills moneyline implies a win probability near 94%, so there is no value to chase on the favorite outright.
Buffalo’s Defense Has Allowed One Touchdown in Three Games
Start with what Miami can produce. The Dolphins have scored 22 points or fewer in seven of nine games and average about 16 points per game. Now a quarterback with one NFL start goes on the road against a defense that has held three straight opponents to 12 points or fewer. Buffalo’s front should also find chances against a Miami line with center Aaron Brewer listed as questionable.
The schedule spot adds to the case. Buffalo hosts Kansas City on Thanksgiving night, just four days after this game. If the Bills build an early lead, the short week gives them reason to lean on the league’s second-ranked rushing attack. The market agrees with this read. The total has dropped from 47 to 44.5 while the spread has barely moved. That points to money on the low side rather than a new view of the matchup.
The risk is plain. Buffalo is scoring 31.9 points per game and could approach this number almost on its own. Miami’s games have also gone over four times in the last five, and a depleted defensive front can leak points quickly. Defensive scores matter too, since rookie Chris Johnson returned an interception for a touchdown last week. At -108, the price requires about a 51.9% hit rate, and the Miami offense is the reason to expect that much.
The Pick: Under 44.5 (-108)
Miami Is Down Three Defensive Tackles
Cook has 971 rushing yards, averaging 5.2 yards per carry on roughly 21 carries per game. He has cleared 100 yards in five of nine games and reached 90 in four of his last five. Miami’s run defense is now missing its top three defensive linemen, and the Colts just exploited that for 172 rushing yards. The price of +110 implies about 47.6%, below the rate Cook has reached the mark this season.
Volume backs the yardage case. Cook has scored a touchdown in eight straight games, and his workload has been steady even in comfortable wins. He carried 31 times in a 23-6 win at Minnesota and finished with 107 yards. Meanwhile, Miami will be leaning on reserves Kenneth Grant, Keith Cooper and Jordan Jefferson in the middle of its line. That is a difficult assignment against a back averaging more than five yards per carry.
The case against is game script. In Buffalo’s 36-10 rout of Baltimore, Cook finished with 80 yards on 21 carries. A similar blowout could push Ray Davis into the late work. Note that this pick and the Under share an input, since both assume Buffalo leans on the run, so they are not fully independent.
The Pick: James Cook Alternate Rushing Yards 100+ (+110)