Thursday’s NHL schedule is packed with playoff-race intensity and several intriguing betting opportunities. With the regular season entering the stretch run, teams are fighting for position and every point matters. That urgency often creates value for bettors who focus on matchups rather than just standings. Continue reading for our Thursday NHL Best Bets March 12 column for our three selections ahead of tonight.

NHL Best Bet: Stars -125 (vs. Oilers)

Dallas enters this matchup as a modest favorite around -130, which falls comfortably within the value range for a contender playing at home.

The Stars have been one of the NHL’s most consistent teams this season with a 40-14-10 record, showing elite balance on both ends of the ice.

Why Dallas has the edge

1. Elite offensive depth

Dallas boasts one of the deepest forward groups in the Western Conference.

• Jason Robertson remains one of the league’s most dangerous scorers.

• Wyatt Johnston continues to emerge as a dynamic young center.

When Dallas rolls its top three lines, opponents struggle to match up defensively.

2. Defensive structure

The Stars’ blue line, led by Miro Heiskanen, excels at limiting high-danger scoring chances. That’s important against an Edmonton team that thrives in transition.

3. Oilers defensive inconsistency

Even with Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, Edmonton can be vulnerable defensively. If Dallas slows the pace and forces Edmonton into a structured game, the Stars typically control possession.

Prediction

Dallas’ depth and defensive stability give them the advantage on home ice.

Pick: Dallas Stars ML (-130)
Projected Score: Stars 4, Oilers 3

NHL Best Bet: Ducks -103 (at Maple Leafs)

This is essentially a pick’em matchup, with both teams priced around -110 on the moneyline.

That creates value backing the more balanced roster.

Why Anaheim is the better side

1. Elite young scoring core

Anaheim’s offense has taken a big leap thanks to its young stars:

• Cutter Gauthier

• Mason McTavish

• Leo Carlsson

Carlsson in particular has developed into a two-way force who drives possession and scoring chances.

2. Offensive upside

The Ducks play an aggressive offensive style and generate high shot totals off the rush.

3. Toronto inconsistency

The Maple Leafs have struggled defensively and sit around .500 this season, which makes them unreliable even at home.

Prediction

Anaheim’s young core pushes the pace and wins a tight game.

Pick: Anaheim Ducks ML (-110)
Projected Score: Ducks 3, Maple Leafs 2

NHL Best Bet: Capitals +181 (at Sabres)

Buffalo is the hottest team in hockey right now and enters as a large -218 favorite, which inflates the value on Washington.

The Sabres are on a massive winning streak and averaging 4.5 goals per game during that run, which is exactly why the line has ballooned.

But that creates an interesting underdog opportunity.

Why Washington is worth the risk

1. Veteran scoring power

The Capitals still have dangerous offensive weapons:

• Alex Ovechkin

• Dylan Strome

• Tom Wilson

Ovechkin remains one of the most lethal goal scorers in hockey and can swing games with one shot.

2. Sabres regression potential

Buffalo’s recent scoring surge is unlikely to continue forever. When a team is priced this high during a hot streak, the underdog often carries value.

3. Capitals offensive capability

Washington averages over 3 goals per game, showing they can keep up in a high-scoring matchup.

Prediction

Buffalo is the better team overall, but the odds create strong value on Washington in a potential upset.

Pick: Washington Capitals ML (+180)
Projected Score: Capitals 4, Sabres 3

Thursday NHL Best Bet March 12

1. Dallas Stars -125
2. Anaheim Ducks -103
3. Washington Capitals +181

Follow: Twitter/X · Bluesky · Facebook

Responsible Gaming

For help and resources, visit our Responsible Gaming page or the National Council on Problem Gambling.

Affiliate Disclosure

We may receive affiliate commissions if you sign up through links on our site. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure.