Our Penguins vs Stars prediction for Sunday night starts with a schedule gap. Pittsburgh lost 4-3 in Nashville on Saturday and now plays the back half of a back-to-back in Dallas. The rested Stars sit at -225 on the moneyline, and the total has dropped to 6.0. Below, we break down the goaltending, the line movement and the two plays that stand out.
Pittsburgh Penguins vs. Dallas Stars — Game Info
| Where | American Airlines Center, Dallas Texas |
| When | November 22 – 7:00 PM ET |
| TV | Prime Video, SportsNet Pittsburgh |
Pittsburgh Penguins vs. Dallas Stars Odds
| Puck Line | Moneyline | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penguins | +1.5 (-135) | +185 | O 6.0 (-120) |
| Stars | -1.5 (+115) | -225 | U 6.0 (+100) |
Odds accurate as of November 22, 2026 via TheSpread.com. Odds change, get the latest NHL Odds – Futures – Props
Penguins vs. Stars Prediction — What Did the Drop From 6.5 Say?
This total opened at 6.5 with the Under priced at -122. It now sits at 6.0, a full half-goal lower, with the Over at -120. That is a meaningful move in hockey. A total of six can also land exactly, so the move changes the outcomes and not just the price.
Start with Dallas. The Stars allow fewer than 24 shots per game and 2.45 goals per game, which describes a team that controls play without the puck. Their penalty kill also takes away Pittsburgh’s power play as a scoring route. Meanwhile, the Dallas offense is efficient rather than explosive at 2.82 goals per game. A Pittsburgh team playing its second game in two nights is a poor candidate to tilt the ice in an open game.
Pittsburgh’s own shot volume sits at a little over 27 per game. Against a Dallas team that concedes fewer than 24, that volume is likely to shrink. Oettinger’s four shutouts also show how often this structure has produced quiet nights. Fewer shots, combined with few power-play chances that convert, is the core of a low-event game.
The risk is Pittsburgh’s goaltending. Murashov allowed four goals on 29 shots Saturday, and Silovs carries a .873 save percentage. Dallas could reach four goals on its own. Empty-net goals are the other threat, since a late one-goal game often becomes a two-goal game. In addition, the best number is gone. At +100, the price needs a 50 percent read, and a final total of exactly six is a push. A game tied after 60 minutes also adds a goal for totals purposes.
The Pick: Under 6.0 (+100)
Penguins vs. Stars Prediction — Nashville Saturday, Dallas Sunday
The schedule spot favors Dallas. Pittsburgh played Saturday night in Nashville, while the Stars have been off since Thursday. The Penguins are also without Malkin and have lost eight of their last 10. Dallas, by contrast, keeps winning close games, as it did in Las Vegas, which we previewed in our Stars vs. Golden Knights breakdown.
The price is steep. At -225, the break-even rate is 69.2 percent, so there is little margin for error. The puck line at +115 is tempting, but that number has drifted from +100 at the open while the moneyline held. That drift argues against needing a two-goal margin. The case against Dallas is real, too. Karlsson has been productive on the road, and Pittsburgh already beat the Stars once in a shootout. This play also leans on the same Dallas defensive structure as the total, so the two are not independent.
The vehicle matters here. The full-game moneyline includes overtime and the shootout, which suits a read about Dallas winning the game however it ends. Dallas does not need to win big for this read to pay. A 3-2 Dallas win in overtime still cashes, while it would lose on the puck line.
The Pick: Stars Moneyline (-225)
Our Final Word on Penguins vs. Stars
Both plays rest on one idea. A rested Dallas team that suppresses shots should control a tired Pittsburgh team that has struggled in goal. If the Penguins confirm a starter in form, or if Oettinger sits, revisit both reads before puck drop.
Under 6.0 (+100) is the stronger play because the total dropped a full half-goal from the open and Dallas allows just 2.45 goals per game. The Stars moneyline (-225) follows from the schedule edge, with Pittsburgh on the second night of a back-to-back after losing in Nashville.