Blues vs Penguins Prediction Nov. 19: Is a Well Rested Pittsburgh The Best Bet?

The St. Louis Blues travel to Pittsburgh to take on Sidney Crosby and the Penguins on Thursday night November 19, 2026. The St. Louis Blues travel to Pittsburgh to take on Sidney Crosby and the Penguins on Thursday night November 19, 2026.

Our Blues vs. Penguins prediction starts in the crease, because that is where Thursday’s game is most lopsided on paper. The St. Louis Blues (10-9-2) visit the Pittsburgh Penguins (7-11-2) at PPG Paints Arena with the moneyline priced as a dead pick’em at -110 on both sides. The total sits at 6.5. However, the overnight movement on the puck line and the total says the market has a view. That view lines up with what the goaltending numbers show. Below we break down the starters, the schedule spot and the special teams before landing on two plays.

St. Louis Blues vs. Pittsburgh Penguins — Game Info

WherePPG Paints Arena, Pittsburgh PA
WhenNovember 19 – 7:00 PM ET
TVSportsNet Pittsburgh, Blue Note+, ESPN+

Does Well Rested Pittsburgh at Home Give Them The Edge Over St. Louis?

Start with the goaltending, since it is the biggest input to this price. Joel Hofer is the projected starter for St. Louis, though his start is not yet confirmed. He is 8-6-1 with a 2.27 goals-against average, a .921 save percentage and two shutouts. His most recent standout was a 29-save shutout in an eight-round shootout win at Utah on November 12. Jordan Binnington handled Tuesday’s game instead and stopped 25 of 31 shots. His season line is 2-3-1 with a .843 save percentage, so a surprise swap would change this read entirely.

Pittsburgh’s crease is less settled. Arturs Silovs is listed as the projected starter, but he is also unconfirmed. He is 5-6-1 with a 3.35 goals-against average and a .873 save percentage. Meanwhile, Sergei Murashov started the last two games, including a 34-save shootout win at San Jose. Murashov is 2-5-1 with a save percentage just under .895. Either way, the Penguins will start a goalie whose save percentage trails Hofer’s by more than 25 points.

The schedule spot leans the other way. Pittsburgh last played Saturday, a 4-1 home loss to Ottawa, so it arrives fully rested. St. Louis played at home Tuesday and outlasted Anaheim in a wild 8-6 win. Wednesday was an off day, so this is not a back-to-back. Still, it is a one-time-zone road trip after a chaotic game. The Blues are 4-6-1 on the road and 5-4-1 in their last 10. The Penguins are 4-4-1 at home and 4-5-1 in their last 10, sitting seventh in the Metropolitan Division.

On special teams, Pittsburgh ranks 20th on the power play at 20% and 14th on the penalty kill at 79.6%. St. Louis has scored a power-play goal in four of its last five games against the Penguins. Injuries hit Pittsburgh harder, with Bryan Rust, Ryan Graves and Elmer Soderblom on injured reserve. The Blues are without Torey Krug, Dillon Dube and Tyler Tucker. Ben Kindel now centers Pittsburgh’s second line between Tommy Novak and Yegor Chinakhov.

St. Louis Blues vs. Pittsburgh Penguins Odds

Puck LineMoneylineTotal
Blues-1.5 (+225)-110O 6.5 (+102)
Penguins+1.5 (-275)-110U 6.5 (-122)

Odds accurate as of November 19, 2026 via TheSpread.com. Odds change, get the latest NHL Odds – Futures – Props

St. Louis Blues vs. Pittsburgh Penguins — Who Is the Public Betting?

Blues65%35%Penguins

See the latest NHL Public Betting Splits and make smarter wagers!

Does Hofer’s .921 Travel to PPG Paints Arena?

A pick’em price at -110 asks a bettor to win 52.4% of the time. The question is whether the goaltending gap pushes St. Louis clear of that mark. We think it does. Hofer has been the steadier of the two projected starters by a wide margin. His coach, Jim Montgomery, has praised his play since the first game of the season. Pittsburgh’s two options have combined for a season of sub-.895 work. In hockey, a crease edge that size often matters more than the standings.

The market offers mild support. Pittsburgh opened as the puck-line favorite at -1.5 (+230). Overnight, the board flipped, and St. Louis is now the side laying -1.5 at +225. That move went with the 65% of spread tickets on the Blues, so it is a weak signal on its own. Even so, the moneyline has held at -110 despite that action. In other words, the price on St. Louis to simply win has not been bid up, so the edge has not been priced away yet.

There is a real case for Pittsburgh, too. The Penguins are rested, while the Blues are coming off a draining 14-goal game and a flight east. Pittsburgh’s power play can also punish a Blues penalty kill that allowed two goals Tuesday. Also, if Binnington starts instead of Hofer, this read collapses. Because a large share of NHL games finish within one goal, needing a two-goal margin at a 30.8% break-even is not where the value sits. This read covers the full game, including overtime and the shootout. The board prices a trip to overtime at +265, a 27.4% break-even. With that much riding on what happens after 60 minutes, a full-game read suits a goaltending edge better than a regulation-only one.

The Pick: Blues Moneyline (-110)

What Is the Overnight Move on 6.5 Telling Us?

The total opened at 6.5 with the Over at -105 and the Under at -115. The number has not changed, but the prices have. The Over has drifted out to +102 and the Under has shortened to -122. That is the market leaning one way without moving the line. Moreover, 6.5 is a high number for an NHL game, and Hofer has already posted two shutouts this season. Tuesday’s 14-goal game may also have inflated the number more than it should, since the market tends to overreact to the last result.

The risks are obvious. Pittsburgh’s goaltending is a genuine Over case, and the Blues’ penalty kill allowed two power-play goals on four minors Tuesday. Empty-net goals can turn a 4-2 game into 5-2 in the final minute. In addition, this full-game total includes overtime and the shootout, so a tie after 60 minutes adds at least one goal. The shortened side now carries a 55.0% break-even, so the edge is thinner than it was at the open. This play leans on the same Hofer start as our first pick, so the two are not independent.

The Pick: Under 6.5 (-122)

Our Final Word on Blues vs. Penguins

This game turns on the morning skate. If Hofer is confirmed, St. Louis carries the clearer goaltending edge into a fair price. If Binnington gets a second straight start, both plays lose their main support, so check the confirmed starters before puck drop. For more on the Blues’ last outing, see our Ducks vs. Blues prediction from Tuesday.

We like the Blues on the moneyline at -110 because Hofer’s .921 save percentage gives them the stronger projected goaltender in a pick’em game. We also like the Under 6.5 at -122 because the market has pushed the Over price out on a high total.