NHL Best Bets October 16 – Expert Picks & Predictions

Last Updated on October 16, 2025 7:30 am by admin

Thursday’s NHL slate brings sharper markets and smaller edges, but our analytics still flag three confident plays for tonight’s action. Our NHL Best Bets October 16 targets value on totals and short favorites using form, goaltending metrics, and price context to identify optimal exposure before puck drop.For a quick refresher on price drift and how to shop the best NHL number, see our Closing Line Value primer and How To Shop Betting Lines.

🔔 Follow updates: Twitter/X · Bluesky · Facebook

💸 Compare Live NHL Odds & Shop Lines

NHL Best Bets October 16 — Today’s Picks

1) Rangers @ Maple Leafs — Under 6.0 (−110)

  • Official Line: Maple Leafs −147 / Rangers +127 — Total 6.0 (Over −110 / Under −110) | PL NYR +1.5 (−205) / TOR −1.5 (+173)
  • Angle (Today’s NHL Picks): Early-season structure points toward controlled pace. Toronto’s top-six can finish, yet New York’s defensive shell reduces rush trading; at a flat 6.0, the Under remains viable unless books drift to 6.5.

2) Oilers @ Islanders — Oilers −1.5 (+145)

  • Official Line: Oilers −170 / Islanders +145 — Total 6.0 (−110/−110) | PL EDM −1.5 (+145) / NYI +1.5 (−170)
  • Angle (Best Bet #2): Edmonton’s pace and PP entries generate sustained chance quality. If the Isles chase late, open ice boosts margin potential; plus-money puck line outperforms laying a heavy moneyline.

3) Canucks @ Stars — Stars ML (−177)

  • Official Line: Stars −177 / Canucks +153 — Total 6.0 (−110/−110) | PL VAN +1.5 (−170) / DAL −1.5 (+145)
  • Angle (Expert Pick): Dallas’s interior control and rebound management dampen Vancouver’s volatility. In a 6.0 total environment, the home ML is the steadier exposure.

💰 Find The Best NHL Prices Before You Bet

Odds & Goalie Notes

  • Rangers @ Maple Leafs (7:00 ET): TOR −147 / NYR +127; Total 6.0; PL NYR +1.5 (−205) / TOR −1.5 (+173). Goalie outlook: Expect standard starters on regular rest; the Under leans on average-to-strong save rates and restrained odd-man rushes.
  • Oilers @ Islanders (7:30 ET): EDM −170 / NYI +145; Total 6.0; PL EDM −1.5 (+145) / NYI +1.5 (−170). Goalie outlook: Edmonton’s volume and east-west passing test rebound control; Islanders can steady with net-front clears if they avoid extended PK time.
  • Canucks @ Stars (8:00 ET): DAL −177 / VAN +153; Total 6.0; PL VAN +1.5 (−170) / DAL −1.5 (+145). Goalie outlook: Stars’ crease profile limits second chances; Vancouver’s path is quality spikes rather than sheer volume.

Betting Angles & Late Movement

  • Totals holding at 6.0 reflect tempered pace projections; however, any late move to 6.5 would materially change exposure on Toronto–New York.
  • Market confidence on Edmonton and Dallas has not inflated prices despite public lean, suggesting balanced liability across books.
  • Discipline on specials should dictate variance: fewer whistles favor favorites; penalty-ridden stretches raise volatility for dogs and overs.

Expert Picks — NHL Best Bets October 16

We’re siding with structure over chaos tonight: Under 6.0 in Toronto–New York, Oilers −1.5 at plus money for margin, and Stars ML for consistent interior control. If prices swing, reassess totals first, then derivatives on favorites.

Responsible Gaming

Wager responsibly and set limits. If betting stops being fun or feels out of control, seek help right away. Read our full policy at Responsible Gaming, and visit the National Council on Problem Gambling for resources including confidential support.

Affiliate Disclosure

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you click and make a purchase or deposit, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our recommendations are editorially independent and based on analysis. For more information, please review our full policy: Affiliate Disclosure.