Yankees vs. Blue Jays Wednesday Pick

New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays, 6/5/2019 Predictions & Odds

The Blue Jays pulled off the upset on Tuesday night but will the Yankees rebound with a victory and a cover for bettors on Wednesday when these AL East rivals meet again at 7:07 p.m. ET?

Game Snapshot & Odds

915 New York Yankees (-210) at 916 Toronto Blue Jays (+165); 8.5 runs

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

7:07 p.m. ET, Rogers Centre, Toronto, Ontario

Compare odds and from multiple different online sportsbooks and shop for the best lines at our new Baseball Odds & Betting Page.

Public Betting Trends

According to our MLB Public Betting Chart page, 80% of the betting tickets are on the Yankees to beat the Blue Jays on the moneyline.

New York Yankees Fantasy Spin

Aaron Hicks doubled and ripped a solo home run Tuesday in Toronto. He scored on Clint Frazier's two-run shot in the fourth inning before belting a no-doubter off of reliever Joe Biagini in the eighth. The homer cut the Yankees' deficit to one, but that's as close as they would get. Hicks has gotten off to a slow start since making his season debut three weeks ago, but he makes for a nice buy low target.

Toronto Blue Jays Fantasy Spin

Blue Jays recalled OF Teoscar Hernandez from Triple-A Buffalo. Hernandez will get another shot in Toronto after posting decent numbers during his three-week stretch at the Triple-A level. He had batted just .189/.262/.299 with 42 strikeouts through his first 141 plate appearances this season with the Blue Jays. There's not a ton of fantasy appeal here, though Hernandez should start semi-regularly in right field, with Randal Grichuk moving over to center. Jonathan Davis was optioned back to Buffalo in a corresponding 25-man roster move.

MLB Betting Trends

New York

The over is 5-2 in the last seven meetings between these two teams.


The under is 34-16-1 in the last 51 meetings between these two teams in Toronto.


The Yankees are 5-0 in James Paxton’s last five starts and are 36-17 in their last 53 games overall. They’re also 7-2 in their last nine road games, 50-20 in their last 70 games coming off a loss and have won 39 of their last 57 games versus a right-handed starter. The Blue Jays, meanwhile, are 4-10 in their last 14 games against the Yankees despite beating their AL East counterparts last night. They’re also 1-5 in Trent Thornton’s last six home starts and are winless in their last eight games following a win.

Tuesday MLB Prediction: New York Yankees -1.5 (-125)


MLB Headlines

MLB Predictions & Picks

Thumbnail Dodgers vs. Braves Game 6 Prediction The Dodgers’ season will be on the line tonight at 7:08 p.m. ET when they play Game 6 of the NCLS versus the Braves. With so much uncertainty surrounding L.A.’s pitching...
Thumbnail Red Sox vs. Astros Game 6 Prediction The Astros will look to deliver the knockout blow to the Red Sox’ World Series hopes in Game 6 of the ALCS on Friday night at 8:08 p.m. ET. That said, with...
Thumbnail Dodgers vs. Braves MLB Prediction Game 4 of the NLCS will take place between the Braves and Dodgers at 8:08 p.m. ET on Wednesday night. Will the Dodgers even up the series at two games apiece or is...
Thumbnail Astros vs. Red Sox Game 5 Prediction The ALCS is now all tied at two games apiece following the Astros’ come-from-behind victory over the Red Sox on Tuesday night. Who has the edge in Game 5 this...
Thumbnail Astros vs. Red Sox Game 4 Prediction The Boston Red Sox have taken a 2-1 series lead in their best-of-seven matchup with the Houston Astros after routing the visitors on Monday night. Will tonight’s game...