Advertisement

 The Bowl Championship Series is set and as always there are some things that just don't add up. You've got questions and we've got answers:
Q: Why did LSU make it to the title game over those other two-loss teams?
A: The Southeastern Conference is the toughest league in the nation - though the margin isn't quite as great as the folks down South want to believe - and the Tigers get bonus points for winning it. Also, that 48-7 win against Virginia Tech still looks good three months later.
Q: Why did Kansas get an at-large bid and not Big 12 rival Missouri?
A: First off, the rules are one at-large bid per conference. Secondly, after the championship game is set, it's not about putting the best teams in the other games. It's about drawing TV viewers and tourists for bowl organizers. Neither Kansas nor Missouri are ratings grabbers. but the Jayhawks figure to travel better so they go to the Orange Bowl and the Tigers, who beat KU and were a win away from the title game, go to the Cotton Bowl. It's not fair, but it's within the rules.
Q: Was it fair Georgia got jumped by LSU in the final standings?
A: Yes. The rules say a team doesn't have to win its conference to play in the championship game. It's a good rule to protect against extraordinary circumstances. Maybe a team goes 11-1 with some great nonconference victories but loses the league to a team with three losses. This was NOT an extraordinary circumstance. LSU and Georgia had the same amount of losses and the Bulldogs got pounded by the Tennessee team the Tigers beat for the SEC title.
Q: Did Hawaii deserve to get in?
A: Sure. The undefeated Warriors needed to finish in the top 12 and they came in 10th. They did what was asked of them. And beyond that, it's good to have Hawaii in the Sugar Bowl against Georgia just for the curiosity factor. We'll find out once and for all if Colt Brennan and crew can hang with the big boys.
Q: Does Hawaii deserve to be playing in the national championship game?
A: Please. The Warriors' nonconference schedule was pitiful (it doesn't matter if it's not their fault) and the Western Athletic Conference just isn't good enough to justify Hawaii playing for a title. Washington, one of the worst teams in the Pac-10, beat Boise State, the second-best team in the WAC, and nearly beat Hawaii.
Q: Aside from LSU and Ohio State, which team benefited most from Saturday's shake-up.
A: Illinois. The only way the Illini, who had a great turnaround season from 2-10 to 9-3, were getting into the BCS was if Ohio State ended up in the title game and the Rose Bowl was left looking for a Big Ten team. Congratulations, Ron Zook. Have fun against Southern California.
Q: Aside from Missouri, which team suffered the most from Saturday's results.
A: Arizona State. Washington cost the Sun Devils and the Pac-10 millions by not being able to put away Hawaii. If the Warriors lose, Arizona State gets in. The Warriors didn't and now the Sun Devils aren't even playing on New Year's Day. Hello, Holiday Bowl.
---
Ralph D. Russo covers college football for The Associated Press. Write to him at rrusso(at)ap.org.

Recent NCAAF Discussions

ACC Conference Preview on Mon, Jul 2016 by Blade
Handicapping 2016 Win Totals on Mon, Jul 2016 by Blade
Big 12 Conference Betting Preview on Mon, Jul 2016 by Blade
2016 College Conference Previews on Sun, Jul 2016 by Blade
Advertisement

NCAAF Headlines

More inNCAAF News  

NCAAF Top Stories

Thumbnail Washington State Win Total Prediction After winning 10 games a year ago, will the Washington State Cougars build off their 2015 campaign or take a step back in 2016?
Thumbnail Oklahoma State Season Win Total Prediction Even in the pass-happy Big 12, a true contender for the conference championship must gain tough yards on the ground. That explains precisely where Oklahoma...
Thumbnail Wisconsin Win Total Prediction After a 10-win season in 2015, can the Wisconsin Badgers make a push for the Big Ten Championship in 2016?
Thumbnail Florida Season Win Total Prediction   The ever-brief Will Muschamp era left the bulk of Florida fans in a state of discontent. There seems to be a profound sense of renewed hope, however, under Jim...
Thumbnail Georgia Season Win Total Prediction A powerhouse division, the SEC East is not. Will the competition be pedestrian enough, though, to let Georgia capture the crown in Kirby Smart’s first year on the job?
More inNCAAF Articles  

NCAAF Team Pages