2012 - R.A. Dickey, New York
2011 - Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles
2010 - x-Roy Halladay, Philadelphia
2009 - Tim Lincecum, San Francisco
2008 - Tim Lincecum, San Francisco
2007 - x-Jake Peavy, San Diego
2006 - Brandon Webb, Arizona
2005 - Chris Carpenter, St. Louis
2004 - Roger Clemens, Houston
2003 - Eric Gagne, Los Angeles
2002 - x-Randy Johnson, Arizona
2001 - Randy Johnson, Arizona
2000 - Randy Johnson, Arizona
1999 - Randy Johnson, Arizona
1998 - Tom Glavine, Atlanta
1997 - Pedro Martinez, Montreal
1996 - John Smoltz, Atlanta
1995 - x-Greg Maddux, Atlanta
1994 - x-Greg Maddux, Atlanta
1993 - Greg Maddux, Atlanta
1992 - Greg Maddux, Chicago
1991 - Tom Glavine, Atlanta
1990 - Doug Drabek, Pittsburgh
1989 - Mark Davis, San Diego
1988 - x-Orel Hershiser, Los Angeles
1987 - Steve Bedrosian, Philadelphia
1986 - Mike Scott, Houston
1985 - x-Dwight Gooden, New York
1984 - x-Rick Sutcliffe, Chicago
1983 - John Denny, Philadelphia
1982 - Steve Carlton, Philadelphia
1981 - Fernando Valenzuela, Los Angeles
1980 - Steve Carlton, Philadelphia
1979 - Bruce Sutter, Chicago
1978 - Gaylord Perry, San Diego
1977 - Steve Carlton, Philadelphia
1976 - Randy Jones, San Diego
1975 - Tom Seaver, New York
1974 - Mike Marshall, Los Angeles
1973 - Tom Seaver, New York
1972 - x-Steve Carlton, Philadelphia
1971 - Ferguson Jenkins, Chicago
1970 - Bob Gibson, St. Louis
1969 - Tom Seaver, New York
1968 - x-Bob Gibson, St. Louis
1967 - Mike McCormick, San Francisco
1966 - x-Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles
1965 - x-Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles
1963 - x-Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles
1962 - Don Drysdale, Los Angeles
1960 - Vernon Law, Pittsburgh
1957 - Warren Spahn, Milwaukee Braves
1956 - Don Newcombe, Brooklyn
NOTE: From 1956-66 there was one selection from both leagues.
x-unanimous choice

Top MLB Public Bets

MLB Top Stories

Thumbnail Phils hope to survive vs. Bumgarner, Giants The Giants have been thoroughly impressive at AT&T Park this season. Tonight’s starter, though, seems capable of flirting with perfection every time he...
Thumbnail Cardinals ask bullpen to wake up vs. M's St. Louis can’t ask for much more from its starting staff. The bullpen, however, suddenly represents a huge area of concern.
Thumbnail Red Sox vs. Rangers Pick Can the Boston Red Sox pick up another win over the Texas Rangers when they meet tonight at 9:20PM ET?
Thumbnail Pirates aim to shift momentum vs. Dodgers No one outside of the Rust Belt area is quite prepared endorse Clint Hurdle’s club as a legitimate playoff contender all over again. Last night’s turn of...
Thumbnail Mets vs. Braves Pick The Atlanta Braves look to bounce back at home when they host the New York Mets at 7:15PM ET.
More inMLB Articles  

MLB Team Pages