ST. LOUIS (AP) -A federal appeals court upheld a lower court ruling Tuesday that lets a fantasy baseball company use players' names and statistics without paying a licensing fee.
In a 2-1 decision, the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel ruled that CBC Distribution and Marketing Inc. doesn't have to pay the players, even though it profits by using their names and statistics.
The Major League Baseball Players Association had argued that companies like CBC are essentially stealing money from players, who charge big fees to endorse things like tennis shoes and soft drinks. The ruling could have a broad impact on the fantasy league industry, which generates more than $1.5 billion annually from millions of participants.
If CBC had lost, The MLBPA would have gained monopoly rights over publicly available statistics and other information that is used as fodder for fantasy leagues across the country, said CBC attorney Rudy Telscher.
Telscher said the facts and figures are public information. He said it's no different from media outlets that print game tallies to draw readers and make money.
``When you're using mass information, it's protected under the First Amendment,'' he said.
Big media companies like Yahoo, ESPN and CBS pay MLB millions in annual fees to operate online fantasy leagues. Players make fake teams comprised of real MLB players. Over the course of a season, fantasy league players crunch statistics to judge how well the players on their team are performing.
MLBPA attorney Virginia Seitz didn't return a message seeking comment Tuesday. She argued before the court panel that online fantasy games exploit players by effectively turning them into game pieces and using their names to draw more customers.
``There's no way of escaping the fact that players' names are on the product,'' Seitz argued at a hearing before the appeals panel in June.
The court found that fantasy leagues' broad use of statistics isn't the same as faking an endorsement.
`` ... the fantasy baseball games depend on the inclusion of all players and thus cannot create a false impression that some particular player with 'star power' is endorsing CBC's products,'' said the ruling written by judges Morris Arnold and James Loken.
Judge Steven Colloton dissented from the opinion, but he didn't disagree with CBC's claim of First Amendment protection.
Colloton took issue with the fact that CBC initially signed a contract with MLB Advanced Media to pay fees for the players' information, but then backed out of the contract when it filed a lawsuit claiming that MLB didn't have a right to collect the fees.
``That CBC later decided it did not need a license, and that it preferred instead to litigate the point, does not relieve the company of its contractual obligation,'' Colloton wrote.
---
On the Net:
Major League Baseball Players Association: www.mlbplayers.com.

Recent MLB Discussions

NBA - SAN ANTONE - MEMPHIS on Sat, Apr 2017 by Michael Cash
MLB Trends Saturday, April 22nd, 2017 on Sat, Apr 2017 by Blade
MlB AND NBA PLAYS For FRI 21st on Fri, Apr 2017 by Timmy1961
MLB Trends Friday, April 21st, 2017 on Fri, Apr 2017 by Blade

Top MLB Public Bets

#2 966 Tampa Bay Rays  96%
#3 971 Detroit Tigers  92%
#5 979 New York Yankees  90%
#6 969 Boston Red Sox  87%
#7 976 Oakland Athletics  83%
#8 967 Cleveland Indians  80%
#9 951 Chicago Cubs  79%
#10 974 Los Angeles Angels  75%

MLB Top Stories

Thumbnail Blue Jays vs. Angels Prediction Will the Blue Jays make it two in a row versus the Angels tonight when the teams meet again at 9:07PM ET?
Thumbnail Giants vs. Rockies Prediction With the Giants' struggles continuing, will the Rockies hand their NL West rivals another loss tonight at 8:10PM ET?
Thumbnail Dodgers vs. Diamondbacks Prediction Can Robbie Ray lead the Diamondbacks to another victory against the Dodgers when the NL West rivals clash at 8:10PM ET?
Thumbnail Indians vs. White Sox Prediction Will the under cash when the White Sox host the Indians at 7:10PM ET?
Thumbnail Cardinals vs. Brewers Prediction Will offense once again be on display when the Brewers host the Cardinals tonight at 7:10PM ET?

MLB Team Pages